Skip to main content

 


HAVE THE MAN WALKED ON THE MOON?

PARTE II: WHY DID NOT THE SOVIETS GO TO THE MOON?

artticle published on 26 October 2020


        From the short presentation of the space missions conducted by USA and USSR, in Part I, one can notice that, generally speaking, the results are similar.  Both powers achieved significant results in the Space Race. During the beginning period, the Soviets had a lot of successes and were on the top, taking into consideration their achievements: first satellite, first man in space, first astronaut outside a space ship and so on. Lately, the gap was closed. The Soviets have kept the supremacy in Venus exploration, while NASA has focused on Mars, where they have performed amazingly. The Soviets succeeded to get close enough to Halley Comet and collected interesting information. Although they did not send manned ships to the Moon, they intensely explored it, including a remote rover landing (Lunohod 1) which was active 11 months.[1] The Soviet scientists’ achievements were on the same level with the US scientists’ ones. It is necessary to add that nowadays, NASA uses Russian rockets, even based on Soviet projects, to perform space missions. Both powers also suffered major failures: aborted missions, explosion of rockets on the pad or in the air, death of astronauts and so on. In main, one can assess that it is difficult to make a statement about the Space race winner: USA or USSR? But this is less important. All I mentioned above bring up a question: why did not the Soviets go to the Moon?

          The answer is quite simple: Van Allen radiation belt. What is this? The Van Allen radiation belt is a zone of energetic charged particles, most of which originate from the solar wind. The particles are captured by and held around a planet by that planet’s magnetic field. It surrounds Earth, containing a nearly impenetrable barrier that prevents the fastest, most energetic electrons from reaching Earth.[2] The main constituents of the belts are believed to come from solar wind and cosmic rays. The belt is divided into two belts - outer and inner. The inner belt extends from roughly 600 miles to 3,700 miles, that is, from 1,000 km to 6,000 km above the earth's surface. The outer belt extends from 9,200 miles (15,000 km) to 15,600 miles (25,000 km) above the surface.[3] The Soviet scientists assessed that the living things were not able to resist the radiation beyond the Van Allen radiation belt.[4] And the medium distance between Earth and Moon is 384,000 km.

          What happened? During the beginning period of the Space Race, the Soviets launched space ships whose ”crews” consisted of animals and plants and they noticed that the living thing could not survive beyond the protection provided by magnetic field of Earth. Additionally, US physicist James A. Van Allen discovered the radiation belt in 1958. In honor of him, the belt was named Van Allen. The Soviets missions programs’ leaders did not risk sending astronauts beyond the protective shield. They did not have the technology for this.

          By studying, as much as I could, the Soviet and Russian articles regarding the manned ships lunar landing, I noticed they did not directly contest the success of lunar landing and the presence of men on the Moon. On the other hand, they also did not support this matter. They merely provide information about cosmic radiation and the danger posed by them, Van Allen belt and the impossibility of living thing to survive outside its limits.



[1] Article Lunokhod, on-line publication Space.com, on Internet at https://www.space.com/35090-lunokhod-1.html.

[2] Article What are the Van Allen radiation belts?, May 2020, on-line publication Space Center Houston, on Internet at https://spacecenter.org/what-are-the-van-allen-radiation-belts/.

[3] Article Definition of 'Van Allen Radiation Belts', on-line publication The Economic Times, on Internet at https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/definition/van-allen-radiation-belts.

[4] Article ОСВОЕНИЕ ЛУНЫ, chapter АПОЛЛОН 11. ИМИТАЦИЯ УДАЛЕННОГО ЛАНДШАФТА ЛУНЫ. СТЕРЕОСКОПИЧЕСКИЙ МЕТОД ПРОВЕРКИ МАТЕРИАЛОВ LRO and chapter ТОЧНЫЙ РАСЧЕТ ТРАЕКТОРИИ ПОЛЕТА АПОЛЛОН 11, АПОЛЛОН 14, АПОЛЛОН 15 И АПОЛЛОН 17 ЧЕРЕЗ РАДИАЦИОННЫЙ ПОЯС ЗЕМЛИ. ДОЗЫ РАДИАЦИИ, on-line publication ГОРОДСКОЕ ПОСЕЛЕНИЕ ГОРОД ЕРМОЛИНО, section РАЗДЕЛЫ НОВОСТЕЙ, on Internet at https://ligaspace.my1.ru/news/2013-02-24-434 and https://ligaspace.my1.ru/news/2011-04-10-301. 



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

  THE MYTH OF ISRAELI INVINCIBILITY. PART II 1956 – Suez Crisis            Crisis erupted due to the nationalization of the Suez Canal. In 1954, the Egyptian president, Gamal Abdul Nasser, started ambitious projects, including Aswan Dam (on Nile) and armed forces modernization. Initially, he asked USA and UK for funding but was refused. Taking advantage of the rivalry between Eastern and Western blocs, he approached the USSR for help and received a positive answer. Based on Soviet security guarantees, he took a step forward: on 26 July 1956, he nationalized Suez Canal, owned by an Anglo-French company. Due to the highly geostrategic and economic importance of the canal, UK and France reacted. Their first approach, supported by the USA, was a diplomatic one but later, planned a military intervention to seize the canal by force. Israel was included in this plan. According to it, the Israeli forces were supposed to conduct offensive operations in Sinai Pe...
Post a Comment
Read more
  KHARG ISLAND – MISSION IMPOSSIBLE?           The international media is flooded with information regarding the US leadership's intention to perform a military operation to occupy Kharg Island in the Persian Gulf. It is believed that seizing the island, which is Iran's primary oil hub, would deal a powerful blow to the Tehran regime. However, such an operation involves an assault and the occupation of the island by an expeditionary force. In other words, boots on the ground . [1]           Kharg Island is located 483 km from the Strait of Hormuz and 25 km from the Iranian coast. The shortest distance to the Saudi coast is approximately 190 km, as is the distance to the Kuwaiti coast. The island's surface area is about 20 km² . Source: https://www.britannica.com/place/Kharg-Island             A simple consultation of the map and a minimal knowledge of the situation show us ...
Post a Comment
Read more
  THE MYTH OF ISRAELI INVINCIBILITY. PART VI 1978 – Intervention in Lebanon              In 1973, after the Yom Kippur War, Israel already possessed clear military superiority over its Arab neighbors. The defeat suffered and the heavy losses within the Arab coalition guaranteed this reality. The superiority was reflected in the trump cards it consistently held or had regained: strong US support, highly effective intelligence services, air power, and the tactics of (blitzkrieg). Technological superiority was not yet evident.         Israel’s security was already very solid compared to the 1950s and 1960s. Peace negotiations were underway with Egypt. Jordan no longer posed a problem. Syria remained the only neighboring state enemy, but it was far from having the capacity to launch any military campaign against Israel. Other enemies still existed—namely Iraq and Libya—but they were not in a position to act directly. What remained ...
Post a Comment
Read more